Antdony`s Pizza and Pasta in Evergreen

Thanks for making our day and bringing a delivery of yummy pizza, salads and meatball subs! Great service and yummy food just when we needed it!

Been coming here for years nice staff yummy pizza☺

Great pie. Good people.Thx

Great pizza with quality toppings and a friendly and engaging staff 10/10 would recommend!

Best pizza in Colorado.. closest to NY style pizza I know because I lived there! Highly recommend it!

A couple of weeks ago my wife and I made a reservation to take our girls to Evergreen lake to use our SUPs. We stopped at Anthony’s Pizza for a quick lunch to go. The girls ordered slices and we ordered sandwiches. They guy said they had no slices and we would have to wait for them to make them. We waited and waited and no slices. We went ahead and ate our sandwiches because the kids hadn’t eaten yet. I went to the counter to ask about the slices and a tall skinny guy working the pizza oven got very angry and started slamming things around and wouldn’t speak to us! We finally ended up getting our slices but we ended late for our reservation. I don’t usually write these things but it really left a bad taste in my mouth. We won't go back to that location but we do like the one in Denver.

Super cute place, extremely friendly staff and yummy food and drinks. If you're in town stop on by!

Fast service, friendly staff!

Very nice! Great service! Great food fast!

Inedible! Describes it! My chicken parm was probably a 1/2 breaded Breast CUBED ... no cheese in sight on pasta with literally 2 tsp of red sauce. My 2 year old wouldn’t even eat it! My husband had baked ziti... was dry and looked like it was made days ago and microwaved. Wow! Just wow!!!

Wow! What amazing customer service! The staff was very friendly and I would highly recommend it. The pizza was delicious.

Great pizza! Especially after new ownership and management. Great place for lunch and dinner. Very friendly and polite staff. Would highly recommend!

Best pie in evergreen for sure! My son loves the fettuccini Alfredo. New owner/s seem to be putting in a lot of effort to maintain quality.

Called this place to order and the person who answered said word for word “sorry, we have so many orders tonight that we can’t help you”... no more business from me Anthonys!EDIT: changed to four star from one star. Got a personal follow up from a manager (which says a lot) and my next order was very good. Thumbs up for the follow up, Anthony’s!

I love Anthony’s food, but it’s not going to be one of our go-to spots because it has been nearly impossible recently to get them on the phone to place a to-go or delivery order (or even make sure they’re open!). Twice in the past week alone we’ve tried multiple times over the course of 30-45 minutes to get anyone to pick up the phone (well within their business hours!). On another recent occasion, we called at a little after 7 on a weekend and were told they were “done making pies.” I think most people up here try to be understanding of small businesses, but they will definitely lose customers if they keep running their business this way!

I ordered from NY for my nephew who broke his leg. I explained i wanted to surprise them with the food so they wouldn't have to worry about cooking and CONNOR was so sweet and helpful and got the food to the house quickly with an extra treat for my nephew. Next time i visit i will personally thank him. Great Job Anthony's Pizza. Laura Dolan

Service was great, pizza was amazing. According to my 8 year old it was the best pizza she's ever had!

My granddaughter wanted mac n cheese and she loved it. Generous portion, tasty. Salad was fresh and balsamic dressing was flavorful, also a generous portion. We both ordered the small portions and it was more than enuff. Glad we found this place.

This customer service is immaculate! I love the pizza !

Great staff! Friendly place! Will definitely come back!

What an amazing pizza place! They hosted the ultimate pizza party for our scout den. The owner and employees were professional and kind... And the pizza. PERFECT. We'll be back.

This place used to be really good, but as of a few months ago had really gone down in quality. The last couple of times that we have ordered, our food was delivered soggy, it had the wrong toppings(pizzas, salads, and grinders) and took an extreme amount of time to be delivered. We have decided to stop ordering from here. We did give them multiple chances and even called to get things corrected...

The Mediterranean salad was fresh and the pepperoni za was delish!

We love Anthony’s! My husband and I have been coming here since we met in 2005. They have the best pizza!

To simplify my experience at Evergreen Anthony’s I would say it has terrible management and ownership. Whenever my family used to go here with Darren as the owner everything was properly done. Now this place is a joke with terrible wait times, staff, and food.

Ordered an Italian salad and garlic bread. BOTH WERE AMAZING!

Our family loves stopping in here and eating. It’s a easy quick meal for the family and everyone is happy!

This place serves awesome food and is super fast!! 10/10

Had an amazing experience at this location! Staff is very upbeat and friendly, pizza by the slice! Always have promotional deals never disappoints

Dave and his team not only make great pies, they also are a fantastic example of supportive/collaborative efforts within our community. Great establishment.

Amazing place. Good food quick service.

Now under new ownership. Just tasted a slice of cheese pizza and it was excellent. The pizza was baked just right and the crust was soft and flavorful and not chewy like other places. We are in the process of ordering a large pepperoni to go so that the other family members can enjoy.

There were 4 of us none of our food came out at the same time cheese on pasta not even melted by the time our kids pasta did come out our pizza was ice cold the person behind the counter could have cared less that everything was terrible we will not be coming back between the poor customer service and below average food

Service is excellent food also love Anthony's for 20 years

We stopped here after a hike. We got pizza slices, and they hit the spot. Friendly fast service also.

Friendly clean atmosphere. Sat on the patio and enjoyed the food and view of the mountains 😋

Friendly service, good prices.

After living here for some time I finally decided to try anthonys when a friend recommended them. My first pie was so perfect I ordered the same one a couple days later, only to get a pizza so over topped with mushrooms that all the dough is soggy and disgusting. I'll be eating the crush + the 1/2" of pie that wasn't ruined.

Very friendly place and greatService

Best pizza in Evergreen! Huge slices, and great service. Love it here!

Grate please to eat and grate customer service i just love this place

Food is great, never disappoints. Better than Beau Jos if ya ask me!

Very sweet cute style inside they were very willing to do anything

Was visiting for the week doing some cabin improvements and two of my local workers said Anthony's had best pizza. Greeted by a super friendly guy who guided us through their nice menu. They made us a crazy mega pizza, maybe because we looked so hungry and tired. Joked with staff and patrons over the fun size pie. The pizza was awesome all the way to the crust. I also enjoyed their well prepared salads and unique Italian dressing. Staff was super local friendly and made our day. Needless to say we will visit again for the best pizza around. In fact, we did and ordered a small, which of course they made us bigger pizza. Super cool owner with super service to customers!

Love the lunch special, good food for a good price!

Usually love this place however walked in today ordered a slice of pizza and a sausage sandwich. The pizza was served cold and the sausage inside the sandwich was ice cold. Good service poor quality. Out of all the Anthonys I do not recommend this one. Best Anthony's you will find is on East Evans Avenue near DTC or Golden Colorado

Delicious pizza and really good service especially with the new owners. The slices are huge and fulfilling

This place used to be great, but now it is under new ownership and our experience has been terrible. We have tried to place an order 6 times in the last 4 months, (we usually order slices, salads and sandwiches) but EVERY SINGLE time we tried we were told "we are out of slices" - and then they proceed to try to upsell you to an entire pizza!! It doesn't matter what time of day, lunch, dinner, etc…- they are always "out of slices". The last time I asked the manager ‘Coltan’ if I could speak to the owner, and he refused to tell me who the owner was and then hung up on me!!!! Terrible! So sad as this used to be a great place to go.